MikeBuck
Driver

Offline
289 posts [100%]
Abingdon MD
|
| 12:26 AM 10/14/2009 | |
|
For the record, I intended to run the apex banner at the glen. I was well aware w/o it I could not score points, as Clark told me. I just couldn't figure out how to put it on and make it easily removable. I can't run it for autox events because I have to use a different one. DD told me they aren't cheap so I didn't want to waste it. I had it on for nationals though.DD, while I know it is tough to police cars, I don't know with whom the burden should lay. I am not going to go around snooping in peoples cars, even cars of drivers whom are my close friends. I am just going to assume we are all playing by the same rules, but clearly this isn't the case. I got my doors blown off by a certain turbo in each nationals race. A car I saw clearly had an aftermarket BOV (noticed while I was hanging in the tech area waiting for you) and a modified AFM, among who knows what other mods.
Modified by MikeBuck at 12:34 AM 10/14/2009
'88 944 TS - 944 SuperCup #744 '08 Tundra DC 4x4 SR5 5.7L 2007 Mid-Atlantic 2nd place! 2008 Mid-Atlantic 2nd place!
|
ferraridriver69
The Clutchless Bastard
Offline
356 posts [100%]
Isle of Palms SC
|
Re: (garylimey) | 8:36 AM 10/14/2009 | |
|
I am certain the Crowell car is exactly as they raced it. Lol
Karl Troyhttp://www.europeanroadandracing.com 2006 SC SE Champion 2006 SC National Champion 2007 SC MA Champion 2007 SC National Champion
|
fcelenza
Driver

Offline
138 posts [100%]
Demarest NJ
|
| 9:20 AM 10/14/2009 | |
|
Well, I sure learned a lot at Nationals, in this, my first year. No question that it's a very tall order to police a series like this, especially with such crafty competitors. For the most part, I think guys are on the up and up and playing fairly, but as we well know it only takes one or two rotten apples to spoil the crate. And when that happens it takes all the fun out of it for the rest of us who just want to race.
#44 NASA NE 944SuperCup, Top Points Scorer http://www.frankcelenza.com/racing.php
|
johnjohn
Driver

Offline
38 posts [100%]
Montreal Quebec
|
Re: (comatb) | 9:59 AM 10/14/2009 | |
|
Bill,God willing we will all be there to joust! On another topic, I've been following the post from my fellow racers and from my past experience it is always best to speak to the person you have a beef with directly and not air it out here! So, just pick up the phone.
Car #142 Never under estimate your opponent.
|
Clark
Driver

Offline
4 posts [100%]
Gibsonia PA
|
| 1:44 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
Hi All, First let me congratulate all participants of this weekend’s Nationals at VIR. As Linda pointed out yesterday, Apex Performance being the title sponsor was very disappointed in the handling of the banner situation with Karl Poetl. Although he was clearly the fastest car on track during both races, he did not meet the 944 Cup Rules, as he had no Sponsor Banner on the windshield. Linda and I drove to the track Saturday morning and arrived as the 44 Cups were being grid. We watched the race from the deck and immediately noticed Karl Poetl was not running a windshield banner, although he had been sent a banner at DD’s request about a month earlier. After the race, I found Karl Poetl in the paddock and asked why he had no Apex Performance banner on his windshield. Karl said that he had forgotten to bring the banner and that he had told DD that he had no banner on Friday. Further Karl said that Dave did not have any spare banners with him. I immediately went into a slow burn. Here we are at the biggest 44Cup event of the year which was being filmed and the lead car didn’t have our banner on it. Had Dave called us Friday in South Carolina, we certainly would have brought a banner with us to the track and this situation never would have occurred. However, we were never notified of the need. To say the least I was astounded that this “lack of banner” situation had occurred. Dave always hounds everyone until the 44Cup and banner stickers are on the car. Saturday evening before the dinner, Karl Poetl, Bill Comat and Ernie Jakabowski had their cars on display in the dining area. Karl’s car still had no Apex windshield banner but rather his Racers Edge Banner. At this point, I told Dave that I had confronted Karl about the banner in the parking lot and Karls response of…”I told Dave I forgot the Banner yesterday”. Dave’s only reaction at this point was, “ Thanks for pointing that out, I have some banners in the trailer”. As it turned out Dave came back up with a Super Cup banner from his trailer and it was put on Karl’s car before the dinner. From Dave’s reaction …I’d say he knew Karl’s car had no banner and had no intention of applying one. If Dave didn’t know Karl’s car had no banner, he could have politely DQ’d him as a direct rules violation. Instead he chose to cover the situation up. It was as though Karl had been given a special “pass” on the banner. To add insult to injury, Mike Buck told of a situation at Watkins Glen where he had no banner on his car but was awarded SuperCup points. Then I realized, Karl Poetl probably had no Apex Banner on his windshield all year but had been awarded points. As I see it there are 2 issues here: First, Apex Performance as Title Sponsor Of the 944 Cup will not be able to use the National video for any promotion… but Racer’s Edge will. The second and larger issue is the cover up of the Rules violation by the person who is supposed to be enforcing the rules. It’s only a banner but I would think that anyone that has provided the majority of the monetary sponsorship for the 944 Cup over some years is justified in complaining.
|
Director
DD

Online
3919 posts [100%]
Indian Head MD
|
Re: (fcelenza) | 4:19 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
| Quote, originally posted by fcelenza » | | ..... as we well know it only takes one or two rotten apples to spoil the crate. And when that happens it takes all the fun out of it for the rest of us who just want to race. |
I would disagree with Frank. As a driver, someone elses car prep has never taken all the fun out of it me for me. But maybe the drivers outside the top 10 have fun racing for different reasons.
Cup Daddy
|
Director
DD

Online
3919 posts [100%]
Indian Head MD
|
Re: (Director) | 4:35 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
| Quote, originally posted by MikeBuck » | DD, while I know it is tough to police cars, I don't know with whom the burden should lay. Modified by MikeBuck at 12:34 AM 10/14/2009 |
For anyone else who doesnt know, the burden falls on all of us. If you see something illegal, and dont say anything to the driver or a Cup official, you are doing a disservice to all running in the series. And do it when u see it. If you are too shy to speak up at the track, then I'd ask you not to grow a set of balls here on the forum, when its too late. And for anyone to come onto this forum and say or even imply somone has an illegal car when you dont have the facts to prove it does another disservice to the series and the driver. If you care at all about the series, then try to help us regulate the series in a constructive manner. Calling out drivers on this public forum when you havent spoke to the driver or Cup officials about your concerns is not helpful in any way, shape, or form. Please think about the series before you begin typing and hit the Save button. Thank you.
Cup Daddy
|
Director
DD

Online
3919 posts [100%]
Indian Head MD
|
Re: (Clark) | 4:58 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
| Quote, originally posted by Clark » | | .... Had Dave called us Friday in South Carolina, we certainly would have brought a banner with us to the track and this situation never would have occurred. However, we were never notified of the need. .........I told Dave that I had confronted Karl about the banner in the parking lot and Karls response of…”I told Dave I forgot the Banner yesterday”. Dave’s only reaction at this point was, “ Thanks for pointing that out, I have some banners in the trailer”. As it turned out Dave came back up with a Super Cup banner from his trailer and it was put on Karl’s car before the dinner. From Dave’s reaction …I’d say he knew Karl’s car had no banner and had no intention of applying one. If Dave didn’t know Karl’s car had no banner, he could have politely DQ’d him as a direct rules violation. Instead he chose to cover the situation up. It was as though Karl had been given a special “pass” on the banner. .....The second and larger issue is the cover up of the Rules violation by the person who is supposed to be enforcing the rules.
|
For those reading Clark's post let me respond to the accusation of a cover up as unfounded. I was unware of the ommison of the banner on the car until first advised of it by Clark Saturday after the second race, and immediately rectified the problem. And while I had a conversation with Karl about his forgetting to bring Racers Edge decals for all the cars to display, Karl and I never spoke about the windshield banner on his car. I had an abundant supply of banners with me, so there would be no reason for not giving one to Karl to display on his car.
Cup Daddy
|
MikeBuck
Driver

Offline
289 posts [100%]
Abingdon MD
|
Re: (Director) | 5:00 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
| Quote, originally posted by Director » | For anyone else who doesnt know, the burden falls on all of us. If you see something illegal, and dont say anything to the driver or a Cup official, you are doing a disservice to all running in the series. And do it when u see it.
|
I pointed out what I saw to John Brown.
'88 944 TS - 944 SuperCup #744 '08 Tundra DC 4x4 SR5 5.7L 2007 Mid-Atlantic 2nd place! 2008 Mid-Atlantic 2nd place!
|
944 #24
Webmaster

Offline
1243 posts [944%]
Loudoun VA
|
| 8:52 PM 10/14/2009 | |
|
General observation:It's easy to cast stones without taking the proper steps as a competitor to ensure things are on a level a playing field as possible. Every year people complain, every year people leave the Series and almost never do people volunteer their time or money or help making things better. Suggestions are offered on a forum, or in passing in the paddock, but when it comes time for implementation there is suddenly a distinct lack of effort. Everyone cares when it's convenient, or when they lose, and they do so with far greater fervor than they ever think to show appreciation. There is cheating in every form of racing. This Series does the best it can, with its limited resources, to minimize its impact on the results. There will always be people who are unhappy and it's amazing to me that our competitors and sponsor alike have resorted to the Internet. Everyone should be thankful that 944 Cup has consistently put up some of the largest fields and had the least amount of incidents on the east coast. Being away from it all for the last year, I've had a different look at it all. Personally, I think some people take themselves and this sport way too seriously. We are here to have fun and bantering on the Internet, while great at wasting everyone's time, is not fun. Take a deep breath and then ask yourself if winning is the only way you can have fun. If it is, I feel sorry for you. If it isn't, why does it matter so much if someone else didn't get caught? Take solace in the fact that you are legal, you did your best and that sometimes cheaters don't get caught. Granted, I have a vested interest in 944 Cup but if anyone else here was responsible for its success, you probably wouldn't have a series to complain about. Allegations of a lack of due diligence or conspiracy are not only preposterous, they're downright childish. 944 Cup, from the very start, has been about doing the best it can to let the Best Man win. To suggest anything else is laughable. Perspective. It's not something that happens on accident.
'08 spec.B | '85 944 | '03 SV650S | '06 VT750'02 - 3rd | '03 - 6th | '04 - 4th | '05 - 5th | '06 - 3rd | '07 - 5th | '08 - 13th (PT) | '09 - 18th (PT)
|
jrmock
SE Director
Offline
109 posts [100%]
Burlington NC
|
Re: (Director) | 8:38 AM 10/15/2009 | |
|
As usual, I appreciate Chriss remarks. Not to drag this out, but Friday, before lunch time, I was asked to check all the cars for decal compliance. I checked for, and supplied nine different sponsor and 944Cup decals. Out of 26 cars, only three needed the windshield banner. I left a banner and other decals, in the drivers seat for #641, and gave a banner and decals to #05 on Friday. I gave a banner to #94 on Saturday morning. Dave and I both had additional banners with us, so I dont know how anyone got the idea we were out. I reviewed my notebook last night, and did not find #371 (Karls car) on my list. While I could have missed him, I dont think he arrived until later Friday afternoon or evening. Unfortunately, the rest of Friday I spent helping Dave notify drivers and officials of inspections, dyno time, and identifying the camera cars. Then I really got busy working with Tim Pruitt to repair his car, and running down spare parts for John Torgensen. Reverting back to my driver role on Saturday, I didnt think to continue checking for decals. Not an excuse, just a simple statement of facts. Im sure there is enough blame to go around, and Im ready to accept my share. John Mock 944Cup Southeast
|
Director
DD

Online
3919 posts [100%]
Indian Head MD
|
Re: (jrmock) | 10:04 AM 10/15/2009 | |
|
John, thanks for the clarification and your time and effort you have so kindly offered up at Nationals and over the years of being the SE Director. As always, you do a great job and I'm sure I dont thank you enough. Dont know how we would have made it thru last weekend w/o you. And the same goes again to John Brown and Jim Burton, who really were tireless in their attempt to inspect cars for 2 straight days. I know I got a lot of thank you's from drivers, hopefully all the drivers took the opportunity to express their gratitude to you both for your efforts, I'm sure they we're all thinking it. Thank you again from all of us.
Cup Daddy
|
Director
DD

Online
3919 posts [100%]
Indian Head MD
|
Re: (turbo 951) | 7:48 PM 10/24/2009 | |
|
| Quote, originally posted by TurboPooch » | 10/13/2009 ..............I have just one question.In super cup with a four [4] way tie WHY didn't all top cars get dyno. We all new Katz was over???? HE SHOULD HAVE HAD THE RIGHT TO POST AS SECOND OR BE DQ. he started in the back because he was to high. With that SAID you count the point totals.Dave you made the rules , you should have enforced them. You posted it was up to the direr to make sure there cars were legal. katz new Friday his car WAS NOT and made NO attempp to correct. In my mind that will alway over shadow the results ..... |
Not sure if I understand what was being said here by Noel Hall. One assertion is made that nothing was done by Katz to make his car compliant. How this was determined is not clear to me when says the drivers says changes were made. Another assertion was that " we all (k)new Katz was over". Not sure how one would know what "all" knew or didnt know about what Katz was running, or who "all " is here, but my question is how "all" , whoever that is, knew what Katz was running at the end of the day for power to be able to cast a doubt on the Katz finish or will "always overshadow the results" . If "all" are still interested, Katz dynoed well within the legal limits at the end of the day because of changes that were made to drop the performance of the car. So in my mind there is no doubt about the results, nor did Katz deserve any misrepresentation of his actions or his car's performance levels.
Cup Daddy
|
|